Maturity Matrix for Multi-Modal Integration - 4MI
The 4MI tool has been prepared as a part the bilateral technical cooperation project “Integrated Sustainable Urban Transport Systems for Smart Cities (SMART-SUT)” commissioned by the German Federal Ministry for Economic Cooperation and Development (BMZ) and jointly implemented by Deutsche Gesellschaft fur Internationale Zusammenarbeit (GIZ) GmbH and Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs (MoHUA), Government of India.


MULTI-MODAL INTEGRATION
Multi-modal integration (MMI) in passenger transport system provides seamless and door-to-door travel alternatives for commuters.
CORE AREAS OF MMI
There are 5 core areas in MMI which help in achieving seamless travel. They are:
1. Network and Service Integration
This refers to the linking up of routes and services across different modes to create a network. The rapid transit routes and bus routes are aligned and structured as the trunk, feeder and complementary routes so that the modes do not compete against each other and rather act as a coordinated system. Such a system adds to the catchment area of the rapid PT mode, improves coverage and accessibility and connectivity to different parts of the city. Services are also coordinated to ensure easy transfers.
2. Physical Integration
Physical integration deals with the planning and designing of interchanges and station areas where transfers occur between modes or within modes. Passengers view transfers as onerous and hence stops of different modes should be in proximity and interchanges should be laid out well to facilitate easy movement of passengers from one mode/service to another. Easy transfers improve the attractiveness of multi-modal transport systems and are key for intermodal journeys.
3. Fare Integration
Fare integration involves single ticketing and integration of fares across modes, to make passenger transfers between modes and services more convenient and seamless. Integrated fares ensure that there is no transfer penalty and passengers pay for the single journey rather than trips on different modes/services. A single fare medium across different PT modes eliminates the need to purchase separate tickets for each mode making travel affordable and convenient.
4. Information Integration
Information integration provides complete travel information on different public transport and last-mile connectivity modes in the city, helping passengers to make informed journey decisions. It would include real-time details of multi-modal travel options including service details, transfers, availability of service, travel time and cost. Information is made available in a comprehensive and easy-to-use format such that commuters can plan their travel before the start of the journey and/or during the journey.
5. Institutional Integration
Several institutions are involved in the planning, operations and management of urban transport systems. To plan and deliver integrated services, it is important that these institutions work together. This would require drawing out of strategic plans and policies and continuous cooperation and coordination between institutions at various stages of planning, implementation and operations of integrated multimodal systems.
ABOUT 4MI TOOL
In line with National Urban Transport Policy 2006, Indian cities are introducing various multi-modal strategies to promote sustainable transport systems. As cities adopt measures for integrating modes, it is important to assess to what extent multi-modal integration has been achieved. Cities need guidance such that there is a comprehensive approach towards integration rather than adopting standalone measures.
In this context, an evaluation tool for multi-modal integration called “Maturity Matrix for Multi-Modal Integration (4MI)” has been developed. This matrix takes into consideration the five core areas and defines desired characteristics of a fully integrated multi- modal system. 4MI is a web-based tool that can help cities assess where they are in terms of MMI and identify areas of interventions.
FEATURES OF 4MI TOOL
-
Consists of five different maturity levels and five core areas of MMI
-
Enables future scenario creations and comparisons
-
Adopts a simple scoring system
-
Acts as a road map - outlines MMI strategies for achieving higher level of integration
-
Identifies current levels of maturity and helps track progress of MMI over time
-
Allows city authorities to identify areas of interventions achieved across the five core areas of MMI
5 CORE MMI AREAS
13 MMI ELEMENTS
5 LEVELS OF INTEGRATION
13 X 5 MATURITY MATRIX
STRUCTURE OF 4MI TOOL
The 4MI has been designed as a 13 X 5 matrix. The rows consist of 13 elements under the 5 core areas of integration. The columns consist of five levels of integration: Level – 1 corresponding to independent systems and Level - 5 representing integrated systems. Detailed descriptions of each maturity level for the 13 elements are specified based on which users can choose the level of maturity.
Network & Service Integration
- E1. Planning of routes and services
- E2. Service headways and schedule coordination
- E3. Area coverage
Physical Integration
- E4. Proximity of transit stops
- E5. Ease of transfers
- E6. Last mile connectivity to the interchange zone
Fare Integration
- E7. Fare policy/structure
- E8. Fare technology
Information Integration
- E9. Provision of service information
- E10. Wayfinding
- E11. Customer care
Institutional Integration
- E12. Decision making processes
- E13. Data sharing and integration








































